Fashion photography's most consequential moments weren't the prettiest pictures — they were the riskiest propositions. When The New York Times convened a panel of models, designers, stylists and photographers to debate the images that changed fashion most, three cases stood out to me as a genuine lineage: Richard Avedon's provocative Calvin Klein Jeans campaign with Brooke Shields, Andy Warhol's intimate Polaroids of Jean-Michel Basquiat, and Carrie Mae Weems' narrative artistry, which luxury houses now borrow wholesale. Each one blurred a line — between commerce and provocation, between artist and model, between art and advertising — and each blur became a marketing template.
Introduction: Redefining Fashion's Visual Language
Fashion photography did not begin as a storytelling medium. As the Getty Museum's exhibition history records, it emerged in 1911, when the French publisher Lucien Vogel challenged Edward Steichen to create the first artistic fashion photographs — a deliberate attempt to lift the genre beyond garment documentation. Steichen's 1920s magazine work, as one fashion history retrospective puts it, captured "a mood and a narrative that reflected the cultural spirit of the time," fusing aesthetics with commercial expression from the start.
That fusion is the through-line I want to trace. The medium was born from an art-commerce marriage, and every pivotal campaign since has renegotiated the terms. The three cases below each pushed one term dramatically further — and luxury marketing never went back.
Calvin Klein Jeans (1980s): Provocation and Celebrity
Avedon's campaign with a teenage Brooke Shields turned a jeans ad into a national moral debate. The most provocative line in the TV commercials — "You want to know what comes between me and my Calvins? Nothing." — implied Shields wasn't wearing underwear, though she later said she didn't understand the innuendo herself. Networks pulled the ads. Demand for the jeans, as the Times panel noted, skyrocketed anyway.
That double outcome is the innovation. The campaign proved that controversy could be an asset rather than a liability, and that a celebrity's persona could carry a brand's identity more powerfully than any garment shot. Panelist Ian Bradley called it "a milestone celebrity endorsement for the brand," and stylist Cate Holstein observed that Calvin "paved the way for so many other campaigns." In my reading, this is the moment advertising stopped selling denim and started selling a persona — a template every luxury house has since run through.





